Skip to content
Policy

US and Russia Expected to Resist Binding Autonomous Weapons Rules at Geneva Talks

Most of the convention's 128 states parties back a treaty negotiation, while Washington wants a five-year mandate for talks towards a non-binding agreement.

·2 min read

Prefer Nakoda News on Google

The United States and Russia are expected to oppose opening negotiations on legally binding rules for lethal autonomous weapons when states party to the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons meet in Geneva from Monday, Reuters reported, citing diplomats and rights groups. The UN-hosted review conference runs until Friday, November 20. Details were first published by Yahoo News (Reuters).

States party to the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons must decide what mandate, if any, to give the next phase of talks on weapons systems that can select and engage targets without a human operator. Most of the convention's 128 states parties support binding rules. The US, Russia and Israel oppose them, arguing that existing international humanitarian law already covers such weapons, according to the report.

The decision reaches well beyond arms control diplomacy. Autonomous targeting draws on the same computer vision, sensor and decision software that defence contractors and AI developers are now selling to armed forces. Without a treaty, national rules and procurement policies remain the main limits on how those systems are designed and used.

Three proposals are on the table, according to Reuters. The meeting's chair has proposed a two-year mandate to negotiate a legally binding protocol. The US wants a five-year mandate for talks towards a non-binding agreement. The UK, Germany and France back an instrument that leaves open whether it would ultimately be binding.

Russia has not stated its position publicly ahead of the meeting but has resisted a binding agreement before. It plans to block the European Union, which attends as an observer, from taking the floor, Reuters reported, citing a senior Western diplomat.

Diplomats expect difficult talks but believe a compromise is possible by the end of the week, the agency said. Anna Hehir of the Future of Life Institute told Reuters she expects Washington and Moscow to try to water down any outcome, as they did in September.

The convention takes decisions by consensus, so a single state party can block a negotiating mandate. That procedure has kept discussions on autonomous weapons at the exploratory stage for years, and it gives the three opposing governments a decisive say over the wording of this week's outcome.

Campaigners argue that autonomous systems can behave unpredictably and make fatal errors. Human Rights Watch has urged the review conference to take firm action. The United Nations, the International Committee of the Red Cross and the Pope have all warned of the dangers of such weapons and support regulating them, according to the report.

The review conference is scheduled to run until Friday, November 20. Any agreement on a mandate would decide whether the next round of talks is about drafting a treaty or about writing guidance that states can choose to follow.

By

Nakoda News Policy Desk

Regulation, government strategy and the rules taking shape for AI and technology.

About the desk

Related coverage