Dubai Cassation Court Upholds Expulsion Over Fake Thesis Citations Without AI Proof
The ruling tells universities in the emirate they can discipline students for proven false references without showing how they were produced, and rejects a Dh100,000 damages claim.
·2 min read
Prefer Nakoda News on Google

Dubai's Court of Cassation has upheld a university's decision to expel a master's student whose thesis contained incorrect references, citations and court rulings, even though a court-appointed expert could not establish that he had used a particular artificial intelligence tool. The October ruling, reported by Emarat Al Youm on Tuesday, also threw out his claim for Dh100,000 in material and moral damages.
The ruling, issued in October according to the newspaper, also rejected the student's claim for Dh100,000 in material and moral damages. It gives universities in the emirate a clear signal: an institution can discipline a student for proven academic misconduct such as false citations without having to prove how the false material was produced.
The student was studying for a master's degree in international dispute settlement law. In December 2023 he received an email from the university's academic integrity officer alleging that the thesis was not his own work. An investigation report in February 2024 found that AI had been used in the thesis and that academic material had been copied without attribution. The university expelled him and rejected his internal appeal. The report did not name the student or the university.
He then went to court, asking for the expulsion to be cancelled, for permission to finish his thesis and receive his degree, and for compensation. An appeals court appointed an expert, who found incorrect references, citations and court rulings in the thesis but did not conclusively confirm that a specific AI technology had been used.
Before the Court of Cassation, the student argued that the expert's findings did not amount to a conclusive technical finding, that the expert had gone beyond his technical brief by assessing academic integrity, and that expulsion was a disproportionate penalty.
The court disagreed. It held that the lack of conclusive technical proof that a specific technique was used does not mean a thesis is free of other academic violations, provided those violations are established by sufficient evidence. It said the lower court had discretion to weigh evidence and expert reports, and that its reasoning supported the expulsion. Because the expulsion was lawful and no harmful act had been shown, the compensation claim failed. The student was ordered to pay court costs and legal fees, and his deposit was forfeited.
Legal specialists quoted by the newspaper said the case turns on the nature of the violation rather than on the tool behind it. Dr Ammar Ali, a legal consultant specialising in AI governance, said using AI in research is not in itself an academic violation, but liability arises when its output is relied on without verification, particularly when it includes fake references or rulings. He pointed to Article 16(9) of the UAE's Federal Decree-Law No. 31 of 2025 on higher education and scientific research, and to UNESCO's 2023 guidance on generative AI.
Legal adviser Abdullah Majid Al Badawi drew a line between honest citation errors and fabricating a source or judgment. He said the results of AI detection software are indicators that need verification, not conclusive proof. Fatima Abboud Al Mahri, a governance adviser, warned universities against relying only on detection tools and said clear rules, advance notice to students about the limits on AI use and fair appeal procedures make disciplinary decisions easier to defend in court.
Al Badawi said universities should publish clearer rules on permitted AI use, disclosure, reference checking, investigations and appeals.
By
Nakoda News Policy Desk
Regulation, government strategy and the rules taking shape for AI and technology.


